| |
Directed and written by Anthony Minghella.
Will Francis - Jude Law; Amira - Juliette Binoche; Liv
- Robin Wright Penn; Sandy - Martin Freeman;
Bruno Fella - Ray Winstone; Oana - Vera Farmiga; Miro
- Rafi Gavron; Bea - Poppy Rogers;
Rosemary - Juliet Stevenson
Review by TODD MCCARTHY, Variety.com
|
|
The possible upsides of lying and being burglarized are
among the numerous topics held up to the light for close
examination in Breaking and Entering. Anthony Minghella's
film is conspicuously thoughtful and civilized as it provides
a close-up snapshot of particular aspects of life in London
at this moment.
After big international productions The English Patient,
The Talented Mr. Ripley and Cold Mountain, this is the
first time Minghella has worked from his own original
screenplay since his debut film, Truly, Madly, Deeply.
It's very much the picture of a writer taking stock of
the society and city in which he lives, sorting things
out in his own mind in a way that will prove intellectually
engaging and meaningful for an audience.
The public that will respond to his musings is mostly
the same one that reads books and attends serious theater,
the gentrification class that is now gingerly moving into
the film's very specific setting, the dicey but quickly
changing King's Cross area in North London. King's Cross
Station is known to the world as the embarkation point
of Harry Potter's Hogwarts Express, but the real neighborhood
surrounding it has long teemed with immigrants and criminals.
The face of King's Cross is now being altered by England's
biggest urban renewal project, and characters very much
like Will Francis (Jude Law) who, with partner Sandy (Martin
Freeman), has opened a high-end landscape architecture
office in the area. In short order, the building is broken
into not once but twice and robbed of all its high-tech
equipment. Laying in wait at night for the intruder to
strike yet again, Will sees him and chases him far enough
to know what flat he has run into.
Will is most annoyed at the fact that his "whole
life" is on his stolen laptop. That life consists
of a well-appointed but trying home life with girlfriend
Liv (Robin Wright Penn), a Scandinavian woman with a 13-year-old
daughter, Bea (Poppy Rogers), who doesn't eat or sleep
and compulsively practices gymnastics day and night. This
situation deeply concerns Liv, a depressive herself whose
therapy sessions with Will cast light on the deficiencies
in their relationship.
The gradually unfolding story has Will making the acquaintance
of the young burglar's attractive mother, Amira (Juliette
Binoche), a Bosnian refugee and tailor to whose flat he
brings some clothes for repair. Will says nothing of the
crimes, but verifies the guilt of Amira's son by finding
his stuff in the kid's room. In turn, the 15-year-old
son, Miro (Rafi Gavron), finds the business card Will
has left at the flat and now knows the game is up.
With things slowly atrophying at home with Liv, Will
draws closer to Amira and rashly instigates an affair,
prompting unsettling feelings. Amira, who would like to
return to Sarajevo where her husband died, is vulnerable
on every level.
What happens thereon involves several curious turns of
emotions and justice, of both the legal and ethical varieties,
leading to an almost startlingly upbeat and resolved result
for all concerned. As such, this is one of the optimistic
contemporary dramas of recent times. Or perhaps it's just
wishful thinking.
Pic is absorbing, but in a decidedly low-key way. Partly
this stems from Law's character, who is polite and imperturbable
to a fault. As he at one point remarks, "I tidy up,"
a phrase that could be applied to his function with his
family, Amira and her son, his office and the neighborhood.
But one seldom really knows what's going on inside him,
which is a problem when he begins spending time with Amira.
Law's reading of
Will is credible but lacks force, which may or may not
be intentional.
Even more inscrutable is Liv, who suffers from "Scandinavian
spells." A frustrated Will asks her point-blank what
she wants, and it's impossible to know the answer; as
good an actress as she is, Wright Penn can't clarify it.
A related problem is her daughter, whose condition is
so weird one can't get a handle on what to make of it.
Binoche, physically unchanged as ever, plays Amira's
controlled anguish with skill, and Gavron is a very good-looking
kid with presence. Vera Farmiga has a high old time in
her brief role as an Eastern European hooker who would
like to make a client out of Will.
Benoit Delhomme's lensing has an understated elegance,
and Lisa Gunning's supple editing and Gabriel Yared and
Underworld's score is frequently working to achieve emotional
turbulence and counterpoint.
ANTHONY Minghella talks about the challenges
of directing Breaking & Entering and why he
enjoys working with Jude Law
Interview by
Rob Carnevale, IndieLondon
|
|
Q. It's been some time since you wrote and directed
a film set in Britain. Why now?
A. After I made Truly, Madly Deeply I imagined
I was going to make another British-based film and I started
writing a story based on the idea of a break in, called
Breaking & Entering. I write in notebooks and I've
got two which say very proudly on the front, Breaking
& Entering. The idea was I would write a story about
a couple who come home from a party to discover that their
house has been burgled. They try to do an inventory of
what's been taken and they discover that things have been
added. What had been added were somehow indications of
problems in their relationship. I could never really progress
that story very much. But when I was shooting Cold Mountain
with Tim Bricknell we were on top of some hill somewhere,
and I thought I had to go home and make a film about home,
about London, and we got a call from our new offices to
say we'd been burgled.
That call became a weekly call for about a year, where
we had 16 incidents I think - our offices were in the
process of renovation and they were being burgled like
a sport. The people who we left behind while we were away
were increasingly exasperated and worried about these
burglaries. So, something tripped in my head and I realised
that perhaps in that story of burglaries there might be
a way of looking at London. Particularly when I came home
and started to meet some of the agencies around crime
in London - the police, social workers, community. I was
struck by, first of all, how generous, committed and decent
a lot of these people were. But also it made me think
in a way I'd never thought before about the idea of a
victim of a crime and the perpetrator of a crime being
in the same room, what that meant and what that might
do. That's such a theatrical idea apart from anything
else. And so the story emerged by this collision of this
imaginative idea I'd had a decade ago and this real thing
that started happening to us while I was shooting Cold
Mountain.
Q. Was it ever hard shooting on some of the London
locations?
A. Well, we shot a sequence on Primrose Hill, a
very traumatic sequence between Juliette Binoche and Jude
Law, and Harvey Weinstein [producer] came to visit us
that day. He looked at this hill, which was full of people,
and said nervously: "Are these all extras?"
I said that we didn't have any extras, we just had Jude
and Juliette - to shoot in London we have to take what
we can get. It's true to say that we shot the scene for
the better part of a day with absolutely no interference
from anybody, with a great deal of interest and support
and quietness. It was extraordinary and I was very proud
of London on that. We both [Anthony and Jude] talked a
lot about how it was our neighbourhood, how we both lived
close to that hill and it seemed that what could be described
as indifference is sometimes people being good hearted.
I think we found a lot of that when we were shooting,
that it's a wonderful city. The thing about London is
that you can tell any story you want to tell, you can
find anything you want to find. You can find ugliness,
you can find beauty, you can find curmudgeonly people
and obviously generous people. I think the truth of the
film is that we were welcomed in London and we were thrilled
to be shooting a city that we live in and loved.
Q. Did you set out to change the perception of the
Bosnian refugee experience in Britain?
A. Sometimes I come away from press conferences
about other films thinking I wish we'd talked more about
what the film is about. With this one, all we're talking
about - which is wonderful - is what the film is about.
At some level I was trying to write a story about a marriage,
and a marriage in modern London - and a modern marriage
where there's no ring or contract involved. It spilled
out, necessarily, into conversation that I think there's
an invisible class in London that sustains us. If you
took the migrant class away from London it would implode,
it couldn't be sustained if this invisible class disappeared.
As my family is an migrant family and my wife's family
is a migrant family, I have a particular predilection
towards celebrating the fact that it's a fantastic community
of all sorts and all colours and all kinds and all creeds.
It's not always compatible - we share the same geographic
space, but we don't always share the same values or the
same expectations, or the same privileges. That leads
to conflict, it leads to burglaries, it leads to petty
crime. So, inevitably the film takes a view which argues
for compassion and for a second chance. Everybody in the
movie gets a second chance.
Q. Can you talk about your relationship with Jude
Law?
A. There's nobody better to go to work with on
any day than Jude. Not only because of how he is with
me, but how he is with the crew, how he is with everybody
else. I did a day's acting a few weeks ago and for the
first time I experienced what it was like to be a guest
on somebody else's set. I realised that how the other
actors treat you determines how you're able to do yourself.
The one thing that Jude does is this welcome which enables
other actors to do well. So that's part of the reason
why I wanted to work with him, because it's such a great
collaboration.
Q. Can you talk a little more about the conciliation
scene. Was it a kind of conciliation process for the actors?
A. It was the most difficult scene that we shot
in the film because all of the individual actors were
conflicted about what was happening. I then realised that
we were touching on something very interesting, which
is how do you forgive? Is it appropriate to forgive? Is
it right that in this story the forgiveness comes through
a lie? The 'it' of the film suddenly was much more urgent
than I'd ever experienced before.
Q. Do you have any plans to work with Jude Law on something
for the stage?
A. We'd like to do a play I think. I'm a very dull
person in terms of actors. I find an actor I like working
with and I want them to be in every project. I've tried
to get Robin Wright Penn in every movie, anything I'm
doing. And Martin, although he insulted me every hour
of every day of the work, it was still an honour. It was
great to have Juliet Stephenson in this film, to have
Ray Winstone working with me again in the film. I love
that process but in the last year I've done some work
in the theatre again and it was a fantastic experience
for me and I would love to go back and perhaps direct
a play or write a play. And if Jude or anybody else was
interested in doing that, then great.
Q. Was the use of the Bosnian footage intended to
put into context the troubles of these characters?
A. I suppose that one of the things I would say
is that it can't always be that the only place you reserve
judgement is for the underprivileged. If you're saying
this is a film which says, "give everybody a second
chance", you can't be punished because you have a
profession any more than you can be punished because you
don't have one. There's got to be some sense of fairness
in the way that you view all the characters. And I'm not
judging anybody in the film at all. We looked at that
footage from Bosnia and actually didn't use the strongest
parts that we found because it felt like it would have
been exploitive of that material to put it in as profound
a way as it was in its undiluted form.
Just as when we were shooting in King's Cross, Juliette,
Jude and I drove past the floral tributes for 7/7. We
didn't use that footage because it seemed to be trying
to inflate the value of fiction with some of the pain
of life. But obviously I was trying to say "think
again" about somebody you might judge on one level.
In the same way as when I first came to London, I remember
that I was a young playwright trying to make my way and
I was lodging on somebody's couch. They had a cleaner
on Fridays who was Argentinean. One day, she was vacuuming
around my papers and I spoke to her and asked where she
was from and she said Buenos Aires. It transpired she
was a union analyst who had escaped from Argentina and
come to work in London and found work as a cleaner.
I realised straight away, as somebody who'd had quite
an innocent background, that people were not what they
seemed to be in London and the more time that fiction
allowed you to think all the way around something before
you judged them.
|
|